Drill driver or impact driver?

Carpenter driving a screw into a beam with an impact driver, with a drill driver on the trestle beside him

They look alike and both fit the same battery. Yet a drill driver and an impact driver do very different work. One drills and drives screws neatly at a set force. The other drives long screws with short, hard impacts. Below you can read how they work, what you do with each tool and when you want both.

How does a drill driver work?

A drill driver rotates evenly, just like an ordinary drill. The difference is the torque setting: a ring with settings that determines at what force the tool slips. That lets you drive a screw exactly flush with the surface, without overdriving it or damaging the head. In drill mode it doesn't slip and you have full torque for drilling.

A drill driver has a chuck that clamps round and hex drill bits and screwdriver bits. That makes it versatile: drilling in wood, metal and plastic, and driving screws into cabinets, sheet material and hinges.

The DCK drill driver has 90 Nm torque, 19+1 torque settings and a 13 mm chuck. It drills up to 13 mm in steel and 52 mm in wood. It weighs 1.2 kg.

How does an impact driver work?

An impact driver rotates normally as long as resistance is low. When it gets heavy, an impact mechanism engages. A weight inside the tool then delivers thousands of short, rotating blows per minute to the shaft. These impacts drive the screw further, while hardly any of the force reaches your wrist.

That makes an impact driver compact yet powerful. You can drive long screws into beams and hardwood without pre-drilling, and your wrist stays intact. It has no chuck but a 1/4 inch hex holder, into which you click bits and hex-shank drill bits.

The DCK impact driver has 165 Nm torque, three settings up to 3300 rpm and weighs 0.8 kg.

Note: the torque of an impact driver cannot be compared with that of a drill driver. With an impact driver it is about the peak force of the impacts. With a drill driver it is about the continuous turning force.

Which tool for which job?

Job Drill driver Impact driver
Drilling holes in wood and metal Yes, with round drill bits Possible, only with hex-shank bits
Large holes with a hole saw or spade bit Yes No
Fixing cabinets, hinges, sheet material Yes, with torque setting Possible, but you overdrive more easily
Long screws into beams Works, but hard on your wrist Yes
Decking, fences, roof boarding Possible Yes, faster
Working in a tight space Longer Shorter and lighter
Small screws in soft material Yes Too rough

Do you have to choose one?

If you only have the budget for one tool, choose the drill driver. It drills and drives screws, and with the torque setting you can do most jobs in and around the house.

If you drive a lot of screws, for example during a renovation, on decking or in timber-frame construction, you want both. The big advantage: you don't have to switch between drill bit and screwdriver bit. The drill driver holds the drill bit for pre-drilling, the impact driver holds the bit for driving the screw.

On one battery platform, that isn't expensive. Buy the first tool as a kit with batteries and charger, and the second as tool only. How that works out is explained in Tool only or kit: how to save on cordless tools.

And the impact wrench?

An impact wrench works on the same impact principle, but has a square drive for sockets, usually 1/2 inch. It is designed for bolts and nuts, such as wheel nuts, steel construction and anchors. For screws in wood, use an impact driver.

And the hammer drill or rotary hammer?

If you need to drill into brick or concrete, you need a tool with a hammer function. A hammer drill is enough for brick and the occasional hole in concrete. For many or large holes in concrete, choose a rotary hammer. A drill driver without hammer function and an impact driver are not made for this.

Tips for both tools

  • Use good-quality bits. For an impact driver, choose impact-rated bits; they break less easily.
  • When driving screws with the drill driver, start on a low torque setting and turn it up until the screw sits neatly countersunk.
  • On the impact driver, choose a low setting for small screws and a high setting for long ones.
  • Push straight behind the screw. That way the bit doesn't slip out of the head.

You'll find both tools under Drilling and screwdriving, as tool only or as a kit.

Frequently asked questions

Can I drill with an impact driver?

Yes, with drill bits that have a 1/4 inch hex shank. For neat, precise holes, a drill driver is better.

Why is an impact driver so noisy?

That is the impact mechanism. Wear hearing protection if you work with it for a long time.

Do both tools fit the same battery?

Yes. All DCK 20V batteries fit all DCK 20V tools. Read more in How the 20V platform works.

Which battery should I put on the impact driver?

A 2.0 Ah battery keeps it light. For a full day of long screws, choose 4.0 Ah. More in Which battery to choose.