With cordless tools you see the word brushless more and more often. Mains-powered tools still often have brushed motors. What is the difference, and does it matter to you? In short: a brushless motor gets more work out of the same battery and needs less maintenance. A brushed motor is simpler and cheaper. Below you can read how they work and when to choose which.
How does a brushed motor work?
In a brushed motor, an armature with coils rotates inside a ring of magnets. The current reaches the armature through two carbon brushes. These carbon blocks are pressed by a small spring against the commutator, a rotating ring of copper segments. With every revolution, the commutator switches the current to the next coil, so the motor keeps turning.
This has worked well for over a hundred years, but there is friction. The carbon brushes wear, small sparks occur and part of the energy is lost as heat. That is why you have to replace the carbon brushes after a while.
How does a brushless motor work?
A brushless motor is the other way round. The magnets sit on the rotating part, the coils are fixed in the housing. There is no commutator and there are no carbon brushes. An electronic circuit constantly measures the position of the rotor and sends the current to the right coil at the right moment.
Because nothing rubs, less energy is lost to friction and heat. And because the electronics control the motor, it can adjust its power to the resistance it meets. If you drive a long screw into hardwood, the motor delivers more force. When it runs without load, it uses less.
The differences at a glance
| Brushless | Brushed | |
|---|---|---|
| Run time per battery | Longer, less loss to friction and heat | Shorter |
| Maintenance | No carbon brushes to replace | Carbon brushes wear and need replacing |
| Size | Often shorter and lighter for the same power | Often longer and heavier |
| Heat | Stays cooler under load | Heats up faster |
| Power under load | Electronics adjust the power | Fixed curve, drops off sooner |
| Price | Higher | Lower |
| Repair | Electronics can fail, then you replace a module | Simple, carbon brushes are cheap |
Why brushless matters most for cordless tools
On a cordless tool, energy is limited. Everything the motor loses to friction and heat comes off your run time. A brushless motor gets more work out of the same battery. You notice this most on tools that draw a lot of current, such as an angle grinder or a circular saw.
A brushless motor is also smaller for the same power. That makes an impact driver or drill driver shorter, which helps when you have to work between joists or inside a cabinet.
Most DCK 20V tools at ToolMaestro have a brushless motor. If a tool is brushless, it says so in the product name. View them under Cordless tools.
When a brushed motor is fine
On mains power, run time plays no role. The power comes from the socket. A brushed motor is a proven, inexpensive solution there. If you work in one place all day, for example in the workshop, a corded tool with carbon brushes is a sensible choice.
On light cordless tools you only use briefly, such as a small drill driver for around the house, the difference is small in practice.
An example on mains power is the DCK 1400 W angle grinder. It has a brushed motor with speed control, and two spare carbon brushes are included in the box. You'll find it under Corded tools.
Replacing carbon brushes
Carbon brushes are wear parts. They are therefore not covered by the warranty, but you can replace them yourself or have them replaced. Signs that they are worn:
- You see more sparks than usual through the ventilation slots.
- The tool loses power or stutters.
- The motor occasionally cuts out and starts again.
- You smell burning.
Always replace carbon brushes in pairs, even if only one seems worn. Unplug the tool first. The manual explains how to reach the carbon brushes and at what length to replace them. Order spare parts separately under Spare parts.
What do you choose?
- Cordless tool for daily work: choose brushless. You get more out of your batteries and have no carbon brushes to replace.
- Corded tool for the workshop: a brushed motor is fine and cheaper.
- You work in changing locations: cordless and brushless. No cable, no extension reel.
Not sure whether to go cordless or corded for an angle grinder? Then read How to choose the right angle grinder.
Frequently asked questions
Does a brushless motor last longer?
No carbon brushes wear out, so maintenance is lower. The bearings and electronics do wear, as on any tool.
Is brushless more powerful?
Not by definition. Power depends on the whole tool. A brushless motor does hold its power better under load.
Does a brushless tool need any maintenance?
Keep the ventilation slots clean so the motor and electronics stay cool. Blow them out with compressed air now and then.
Can I replace carbon brushes myself?
On most tools, yes. Follow the manual. If you'd rather have it done for you, email info@toolmaestro.com.